Monday, February 10, 2014
What is 'brain dead,' anyway?
You may now be familiar with the very sad case of Marlise Munoz, who lies “brain dead” in a Texas hospital. Or, like many people, you may have chosen to tune out every time the topic gets mentioned because the situation is so awful, and the construct of “brain death” gives you the heebie-jeebies.
At the time she was declared “brain dead,” Munoz was pregnant–14 weeks so. As I write this, her pregnancy is said to be at about 22 weeks. You should know that any baby delivered before 36 weeks is considered “premature.” The earlier in gestation that a baby is delivered, the higher the likelihood is that the child will not survive, or have severe mental and physical impairments. (With current science and medical technology, about 24 weeks of gestation is the earliest boundary of survivability.)
Though the hospital acknowledges that Munoz is indeed clinically ’brain dead,’ and therefore legally dead, administrators there argue that under Texas law they must keep Munoz hooked to a mechanical ventilator and provide her caloric nutrition so as to help the fetus become “viable.”
Welcome to the Twilight Zone, where the law is not clear, and the number of historical cases of brain dead pregnant females is small enough so that either side in this debate can use the evidence to further its case.
Munoz’ husband Erick argues that the hospital administration is a) misinterpreting the Texas statute, since his wife is dead and therefore not obligated to keep her body functioning as a ‘baby production laboratory’ [my phraseology] and b) overstepping its authority in not recognizing either his wife’s prior expressed wish not to be kept alive by mechanical means or his duty as her surrogate to honor her preferences.
On Friday a north Texas judge ruled that the hospital must withdraw the machines by Monday. As of now, no one knows what will happen. Possibilities include a) obeying the order, and stopping the ventilator [update: the hospital will obey] or b) appealing the decision to a higher court.
Erick and Marlise Munoz are (were) trained paramedics, so I assume they are quite knowledgeable about medical issues, and certainly well-qualified to make medical treatment decisions using the best available scientific evidence.
The clash here is about patient autonomy, an individual’s right to decide his/her own treatment (which I will tell you is unusually clear in this case. The vast majority of the time it’s a “best guess”) versus the State’s interest in protecting the vulnerable (fetus in this case). Of course, since this case involves the unborn, people with strong views about abortion have weighed in.
The concept of ‘brain death’ is also confusing. Legally accepted in all 50 states, “brain death” is the irreversible loss of brain function, such that even the brainstem, which controls autonomic functions like breathing have ceased. Therefore the only way to keep such an unfortunate person “alive” is by mechanical means. What the public is uncomfortable with is the idea that a person with a beating heart (the heart muscle can continue pumping autonomously even in the absence of brain function) is “dead.” But by legal and ethical standards, brain death = death. Period.
What adds to our discomfort about the concept is our very humanity; we all still hold out for miracles. Not to rain on anyone’s sunshine, but in brain death there simply are no miracles.
The difference between brain death and a coma (say, like the one former Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon just exited) is that in a coma, the brainstem and other brain parts continue to function, allowing the body to “be alive” in some sense, such that the body can survive in the absence of mechanical means (nutrition must still be provided artificially, however).
My opinion, for what it’s worth (disclaimer: I am only responding to information gleaned from the news, and I am not involved in the case in any way), is that the hospital should respect the wishes of Marlise and Erick Munoz and turn off the ventilator: Allow her to die properly, with the dignity she wanted. Of course, the unborn fetus will then certainly die, too.
Medical ethics is not for the faint of heart.
This post by John H. Schumann, MD, FACP, originally appeared at GlassHospital. Dr. Schumann is a general internist. His blog, GlassHospital, seeks to bring transparency to medical practice and to improve the patient experience.
Contact ACP Internist
Send comments to ACP Internist staff at firstname.lastname@example.org.
- QD: News Every Day--Stroke guideline focus on wome...
- CPR, high-value care, and MedPeds
- Why he had not peed in 2 days
- QD: News Every Day--Is Wikipedia accurate enough f...
- Health: know what, or no how
- Bacteriophages and the spread of antimicrobial res...
- QD: News Every Day--Prevention key to avoiding glo...
- Reaffirming the value of health information techno...
- Another burden for MRSA patients
- QD: News Every Day--1 in 10 practices making progr...
Members of the American College of Physicians contribute posts from their own sites to ACP Internistand ACP Hospitalist. Contributors include:
Albert Fuchs, MD, FACP, graduated from the University of California, Los Angeles School of Medicine, where he also did his internal medicine training. Certified by the American Board of Internal Medicine, Dr. Fuchs spent three years as a full-time faculty member at UCLA School of Medicine before opening his private practice in Beverly Hills in 2000.
And Thus, It Begins
Amanda Xi, ACP Medical Student Member, is a first-year medical student at the OUWB School of Medicine, charter class of 2015, in Rochester, Mich., from which she which chronicles her journey through medical training from day 1 of medical school.
Ira S. Nash, MD, FACP, is the senior vice president and executive director of the North Shore-LIJ Medical Group, and a professor of Cardiology and Population Health at Hofstra North Shore-LIJ School of Medicine. He is Board Certified in Internal Medicine and Cardiovascular Diseases and was in the private practice of cardiology before joining the full-time faculty of Massachusetts General Hospital.
Zackary Berger, MD, ACP Member, is a primary care doctor and general internist in the Division of General Internal Medicine at Johns Hopkins. His research interests include doctor-patient communication, bioethics, and systematic reviews.
Controversies in Hospital
Run by three ACP Fellows, this blog ponders vexing issues in infection prevention and control, inside and outside the hospital. Daniel J Diekema, MD, FACP, practices infectious diseases, clinical microbiology, and hospital epidemiology in Iowa City, Iowa, splitting time between seeing patients with infectious diseases, diagnosing infections in the microbiology laboratory, and trying to prevent infections in the hospital. Michael B. Edmond, MD, FACP, is a hospital epidemiologist in Iowa City, IA, with a focus on understanding why infections occur in the hospital and ways to prevent these infections, and sees patients in the inpatient and outpatient settings. Eli N. Perencevich, MD, ACP Member, is an infectious disease physician and epidemiologist in Iowa City, Iowa, who studies methods to halt the spread of resistant bacteria in our hospitals (including novel ways to get everyone to wash their hands).
db's Medical Rants
Robert M. Centor, MD, FACP, contributes short essays contemplating medicine and the health care system.
Suneel Dhand, MD, ACP Member
Suneel Dhand, MD, ACP Member, is a practicing physician in Massachusetts. He has published numerous articles in clinical medicine, covering a wide range of specialty areas including; pulmonology, cardiology, endocrinology, hematology, and infectious disease. He has also authored chapters in the prestigious "5-Minute Clinical Consult" medical textbook. His other clinical interests include quality improvement, hospital safety, hospital utilization, and the use of technology in health care.
Juliet K. Mavromatis, MD, FACP, provides a conversation about health topics for patients and health professionals.
Dr. Mintz' Blog
Matthew Mintz, MD, FACP, has practiced internal medicine for more than a decade and is an Associate Professor of Medicine at an academic medical center on the East Coast. His time is split between teaching medical students and residents, and caring for patients.
Toni Brayer, MD, FACP, blogs about the rapid changes in science, medicine, health and healing in the 21st century.
Vineet Arora, MD, FACP, is Associate Program Director for the Internal Medicine Residency and Assistant Dean of Scholarship & Discovery at the Pritzker School of Medicine for the University of Chicago. Her education and research focus is on resident duty hours, patient handoffs, medical professionalism, and quality of hospital care. She is also an academic hospitalist.
John H. Schumann, MD, FACP, provides transparency on the workings of medical practice and the complexities of hospital care, illuminates the emotional and cognitive aspects of caregiving and decision-making from the perspective of an active primary care physician, and offers behind-the-scenes portraits of hospital sanctums and the people who inhabit them.
Ryan Madanick, MD, ACP Member, is a gastroenterologist at the University of North Carolina School of Medicine, and the Program Director for the GI & Hepatology Fellowship Program. He specializes in diseases of the esophagus, with a strong interest in the diagnosis and treatment of patients who have difficult-to-manage esophageal problems such as refractory GERD, heartburn, and chest pain.
Mike Aref, MD, PhD, FACP, is an academic hospitalist with an interest in basic and clinical science and education, with interests in noninvasive monitoring and diagnostic testing using novel bedside imaging modalities, diagnostic reasoning, medical informatics, new medical education modalities, pre-code/code management, palliative care, patient-physician communication, quality improvement, and quantitative biomedical imaging.
William Hersh, MD, FACP, Professor and Chair, Department of Medical Informatics & Clinical Epidemiology, Oregon Health & Science University, posts his thoughts on various topics related to biomedical and health informatics.
David Katz, MD
David L. Katz, MD, MPH, FACP, is an internationally renowned authority on nutrition, weight management, and the prevention of chronic disease, and an internationally recognized leader in integrative medicine and patient-centered care.
Richard Just, MD, ACP Member, has 36 years in clinical practice of hematology and medical oncology. His blog is a joint publication with Gregg Masters, MPH.
Kevin Pho, MD, ACP Member, offers one of the Web's definitive sites for influential health commentary.
Michael Kirsch, MD, FACP, addresses the joys and challenges of medical practice, including controversies in the doctor-patient relationship, medical ethics and measuring medical quality. When he's not writing, he's performing colonoscopies.
Elaine Schattner, MD, FACP, shares her ideas on education, ethics in medicine, health care news and culture. Her views on medicine are informed by her past experiences in caring for patients, as a researcher in cancer immunology, and as a patient who's had breast cancer.
Mired in MedEd
Alexander M. Djuricich, MD, FACP, is the Associate Dean for Continuing Medical Education (CME), and a Program Director in Medicine-Pediatrics at the Indiana University School of Medicine in Indianapolis, where he blogs about medical education.
Rob Lamberts, MD, ACP Member, a med-peds and general practice internist, returns with "volume 2" of his personal musings about medicine, life, armadillos and Sasquatch at More Musings (of a Distractible Kind).
David M. Sack, MD, FACP, practices general gastroenterology at a small community hospital in Connecticut. His blog is a series of musings on medicine, medical care, the health care system and medical ethics, in no particular order.
Reflections of a Grady
Kimberly Manning, MD, FACP, reflects on the personal side of being a doctor in a community hospital in Atlanta.
The Blog of Paul Sufka
Paul Sufka, MD, ACP Member, is a board certified rheumatologist in St. Paul, Minn. He was a chief resident in internal medicine with the University of Minnesota and then completed his fellowship training in rheumatology in June 2011 at the University of Minnesota Department of Rheumatology. His interests include the use of technology in medicine.
Technology in (Medical)
Neil Mehta, MBBS, MS, FACP, is interested in use of technology in education, social media and networking, practice management and evidence-based medicine tools, personal information and knowledge management.
Peter A. Lipson,
Peter A. Lipson, MD, ACP Member, is a practicing internist and teaching physician in Southeast Michigan. The blog, which has been around in various forms since 2007, offers musings on the intersection of science, medicine, and culture.
Why is American Health Care So Expensive?
Janice Boughton, MD, FACP, practiced internal medicine for 20 years before adopting a career in hospital and primary care medicine as a locum tenens physician. She lives in Idaho when not traveling.
World's Best Site
Daniel Ginsberg, MD, FACP, is an internal medicine physician who has avidly applied computers to medicine since 1986, when he first wrote medically oriented computer programs. He is in practice in Tacoma, Washington.
Other blogs of note:
American Journal of
Also known as the Green Journal, the American Journal of Medicine publishes original clinical articles of interest to physicians in internal medicine and its subspecialities, both in academia and community-based practice.
A collaborative medical blog started by Neil Shapiro, MD, ACP Member, associate program director at New York University Medical Center's internal medicine residency program. Faculty, residents and students contribute case studies, mystery quizzes, news, commentary and more.
Michael Benjamin, MD, ACP member, doesn't accept industry money so he can create an independent, clinician-reviewed space on the Internet for physicians to report and comment on the medical news of the day.
The Public Library of Science's open access materials include a blog.
One of the most popular anonymous blogs written by an emergency room physician.